When a driver turns left into a pedestrian crossing with the walk signal, the injuries can be life-changing. But even when the driver is clearly responsible, the available insurance may not come close to covering the damages. That was the challenge in this Fairfax County case, where BenGlassLaw helped a senior pedestrian recover $400,000 from two insurance policies.
Case at a Glance
- Case Type: Pedestrian Crosswalk Accident
- Location: Fairfax County, Virginia
- Client: Senior woman
- Accident: Struck by a left-turning driver while crossing with the walk signal
- Injuries: Broken right arm, ankle fracture, concussion
- Surgery: Arm surgery with screws
- At-Fault Driver’s Insurance: Allstate
- Additional Coverage: Nationwide Underinsured Motorist (UIM)
- Total Recovery: $400,000
- Allstate Payment: $100,000
- Nationwide Payment: $300,000
The Accident: Struck While Crossing With the Walk Signal
“Evelyn” was crossing a busy street in Fairfax County on a clear afternoon. She was in the crosswalk and had the walk signal when a driver making a left turn struck her.
She was taken by ambulance to the hospital with multiple injuries, including a badly broken right arm, a hairline ankle fracture, and a concussion.
The arm injury required surgery, with screws placed to repair the fracture. Even after the initial treatment, Evelyn was left with permanent scarring and lasting limitations in the use of her arm.
The driver was cited by police, so establishing fault wasn’t the biggest challenge in this case. The bigger question was whether there was enough insurance coverage to account for the severity of her injuries.
The At-Fault Driver’s Insurance Wasn’t Enough
The driver carried automobile insurance through Allstate, but the policy had only $100,000 in available bodily injury coverage.
By that point, Evelyn’s medical bills had already exceeded $80,000. She also faced the lasting effects of her arm injury, including scarring and reduced function.
BenGlassLaw investigated whether any additional insurance might apply. One potential source was a delivery-app connection involving the driver.
The team investigated the driver’s activity at the time of the crash and contacted Liberty Mutual, the insurer connected to the delivery company. Liberty Mutual ultimately denied coverage after determining that the driver had completed the last delivery and was no longer active on the app.
That left another important source of recovery: Evelyn’s own automobile insurance policy through Nationwide, which included $300,000 in underinsured motorist coverage.
Protecting the Right to Pursue Additional Insurance
Before accepting Allstate’s $100,000 policy limits, BenGlassLaw had to make sure the settlement paperwork wouldn’t accidentally eliminate Evelyn’s ability to pursue her own insurance company.
This was an important detail.
A release can affect more than the claim against the driver who caused the accident. When underinsured motorist coverage is involved, the language must preserve the injured person’s right to pursue additional benefits.
BenGlassLaw negotiated the appropriate release language under Virginia law so Evelyn could accept Allstate’s payment without giving up her Nationwide UIM claim. Virginia’s underinsured motorist law establishes how an injured person can settle with the at-fault driver’s insurer while preserving a claim for applicable UIM benefits.
The distinction mattered: the first $100,000 was not the end of the recovery.
Building the Underinsured Motorist Claim Against Nationwide
With Allstate’s policy limits secured, BenGlassLaw turned its attention to Nationwide.
The team prepared a detailed demand documenting the full extent of Evelyn’s injuries, including:
- The broken right arm and surgical repair
- The screws placed during surgery
- The hairline ankle fracture
- The concussion
- Permanent scarring
- Lasting limitations in her arm
The demand sought Nationwide’s full $300,000 underinsured motorist limit.
Nationwide initially responded with an offer below its available limits. Rather than accepting the first number, BenGlassLaw continued negotiations with the adjuster, explaining why the medical evidence and lasting effects of the accident justified a higher payment.
The firm also coordinated with Evelyn’s Medicare Advantage health plan to address its repayment claims as part of resolving the case.
The Result: $400,000 Recovered From Two Insurance Companies
Both insurance companies ultimately paid their full available limits.
- Allstate: $100,000
- Nationwide: $300,000
Evelyn’s total recovery was $400,000.
The result was particularly important because the at-fault driver’s policy alone provided only one-quarter of the total recovery. By investigating additional coverage, protecting the UIM claim through the release process, and negotiating with Nationwide, BenGlassLaw secured the additional $300,000 available under Evelyn’s own policy.
What This Case Shows
Being hit by a driver who has insurance doesn’t necessarily mean that driver’s policy is the only source of compensation available.
When an injured pedestrian suffers serious injuries and the at-fault driver’s coverage is limited, underinsured motorist coverage may provide another path to recovery.
But getting there can require more than simply submitting medical records. The insurance policies must be investigated, the settlement documents must protect the right to pursue additional benefits, and the injured person’s own insurer may need to be challenged during negotiations.
Evelyn’s case is a good example of why it’s important to understand the full insurance picture before signing a settlement release.
Injured in a Fairfax County Pedestrian Accident?
If you or someone in your family has been hit by a car while crossing the street, don’t assume the at-fault driver’s insurance policy is the limit of what you can recover.
Depending on the circumstances, your own automobile insurance may provide underinsured motorist coverage that can help when another driver’s policy isn’t enough.
BenGlassLaw helps injured pedestrians throughout Northern Virginia investigate available insurance coverage, handle complicated insurance claims, and pursue the compensation available under Virginia law. Contact our team today to learn how we can help you or your loved one.
Our case results depend upon a variety of factors unique to each case. Case results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case.