If the driver who hit you was arrested for DUI, you may assume the criminal case will automatically prove your personal injury case. Unfortunately, it isn’t quite that simple.
A DUI charge or conviction for the at-fault party can be important evidence in a Virginia car accident claim, but the criminal case and your personal injury claim are two separate matters. The driver’s criminal case is about whether the Commonwealth can prove a crime. Your personal injury claim is about whether you were injured because of the driver’s conduct and what compensation you may be entitled to recover.
So, does a DUI conviction help your personal injury case in Virginia? It can, but it does not automatically guarantee that you will win your injury claim or receive a particular amount of compensation.
Here’s what you should know.
What is the difference between a DUI case and a personal injury case?
The biggest thing to understand is that there are two different legal processes happening.
The Commonwealth may prosecute the other driver for driving under the influence. That case can result in penalties such as fines, license consequences, or other criminal penalties. Your personal injury claim is different.
You are seeking compensation for the harm the driver’s conduct caused you. Depending on your injuries and the circumstances, that may include medical expenses, lost income, future losses, pain and suffering, and other damages. The outcome of one case doesn’t necessarily determine the outcome of the other.
For example, the driver could plead guilty to DUI. That doesn’t mean your injury claim automatically settles for a particular amount. On the other hand, evidence developed during the DUI investigation could be very important to your civil claim.
For a free legal consultation call (703) 591-9829
What DUI evidence can be important in a car accident case?
A DUI investigation may produce evidence that helps establish what happened before and during the crash.
That could include:
- The driver’s blood alcohol concentration
- Breath or blood test results
- Field sobriety testing
- Statements made by the driver
- Statements from witnesses
- The police officer’s observations
- Body-camera footage
- Dash-camera or surveillance footage
- Accident reconstruction evidence
- Information about where and when the driver was drinking
A Fairfax DUI car accident attorney investigating your claim may want to obtain and review evidence that isn’t obvious from the initial police report.
That matters because proving that someone was intoxicated and proving that their intoxication caused your injuries are related, but distinct, questions.
What if the driver hasn’t been convicted yet?
You don’t necessarily need to wait for the criminal case to finish before addressing your personal injury claim. In fact, waiting can sometimes create unnecessary problems.
Your medical treatment, lost wages, vehicle damage, insurance coverage, and other parts of your claim still need to be documented. Evidence also becomes harder to preserve as time passes.
If the driver has only been charged with DUI, an attorney can investigate what evidence is available without assuming the criminal case will end in a particular way.
Click to contact us today
What if the DUI charges are dismissed?
A dismissed DUI charge does not necessarily mean you don’t have a personal injury claim.
Criminal prosecutors have to meet a specific burden of proof in a criminal case. Your civil claim involves different legal questions and evidence.
The important question for your injury claim is whether the other driver was legally responsible for causing the accident and your injuries.
So don’t assume that a dismissal of the DUI charge means you have no case. The facts surrounding the crash still matter.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Can a DUI conviction lead to punitive damages?
Potentially.
Virginia has a specific statute addressing punitive damages in personal injury and wrongful death actions involving intoxicated drivers. Under Virginia Code § 8.01-44.5, punitive damages may be awarded when the evidence meets the statutory requirements. One important circumstance is when the driver had a blood alcohol concentration of at least 0.15 and the other statutory conditions are met.
That does not mean every DUI accident results in punitive damages. It does mean that a seriously intoxicated driver’s conduct may create an issue that deserves careful investigation.
Should I hire a DUI accident lawyer if the driver was convicted?
If you suffered significant injuries, it may be worth talking with an experienced DUI accident lawyer even if the criminal case seems straightforward. The attorney’s job isn’t simply to point to the DUI conviction.
A thorough investigation should look at the entire accident, your injuries, available insurance coverage, the evidence surrounding the driver’s intoxication, and the losses you’ve experienced.
You may also have questions about your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage if the other driver’s insurance isn’t enough to cover your losses.
What should I do if I was injured by a drunk driver?
If you’re dealing with the aftermath of a DUI crash in Virginia:
- Follow your doctors’ recommendations.
- Keep records of your treatment and expenses.
- Save photographs and accident-related documents.
- Keep information about the DUI investigation or criminal case.
- Be cautious about recorded statements to insurance companies.
- Don’t accept a settlement before you understand the extent of your injuries and available insurance.
- Talk with a drunk driving injury lawyer if you suffered significant injuries or aren’t sure how to handle the claim.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a DUI conviction prove the other driver caused my accident?
Not automatically. The facts still need to establish that the driver’s conduct caused the crash and your injuries.
Do I have to wait for the DUI case to end before filing a personal injury claim?
No. The criminal case and civil claim are separate matters.
What if the driver was only charged with DUI?
A charge can still be relevant evidence, but a charge is not the same as a conviction. Your personal injury claim should be evaluated based on the evidence available.
Can I receive punitive damages after a DUI accident?
Potentially. Virginia law provides for punitive damages in certain cases involving intoxicated drivers, including cases meeting the statutory requirements concerning the driver’s blood alcohol concentration and conduct.
How long do I have to bring a Virginia personal injury claim?
Virginia generally gives two years to bring an action for personal injuries, subject to exceptions.
Call (703) 591-9829 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form