What Happens When A Jury Awards Me More Than I Sued For?

By

Ben Glass

|

Owner and Long-Term Disability Attorney

Few people envision their car accident case ending in a trial, but it sometimes does. Your case is filed and taken to court when the insurance company and your attorney cannot agree on a settlement. This happens more often than you think, particularly in cases where the medical bills are very high. This is one reason it is so important to hire an auto accident attorney with trial experience.

The Jury is the Unknown Factor in Your Car Accident Case

In a trial, your personal injury case is heard by a jury. The jury is the reason it is difficult to predict how much your case will be awarded. Each jury is different, so the award amount for trial cases vary. When the jury is deliberating, they may decide to award you less, or more, than the amount pursued by you and your attorney.

If you are awarded more than your attorney requested in trial, consider it a success. The jury determined your case merits extra compensation. They likely reached this decision because your injuries were severe or you lost a lot of pay because of the accident. The extra money may be a welcome surprise, but donโ€™t start counting your dollars yet.

The State of Virginia Says You Cannot Recover More Than You Sued For

The Supreme Court of Virginia says personal injury claimants cannot recover more than they sued for. Because of this decision, if the jury awards you more than you expected, get ready for that verdict to be changed. 

The Judge Could Change the Verdict

After the jury reads their verdict, the judge could adjust the awarded amount downward. This may occur in situations where the jury misunderstood part of the trial, and/or their decision is not reasonable. 

There Might Be โ€œDamage Capsโ€ In Your State

The jury may decide to award you $10 million dollars, but the state limits the damage award to $40,000. You may think the jury is aware of this, but they are not. In Virginia, there are no damage caps for personal injury cases unless the jury awards you more than you sue for. This means any amount awarded to you is not limited by state law. There are types of cases that have damage caps in Virginia; those are medical malpractice and punitive damages. Punitive damages are uncommon because your attorney has to prove the person who caused the accident acted recklessly and maliciously

Client Testimonials

View more >

5 Stars

Google Review

I was in a no fault accident and was injured. Melissa & Autumn handled my case with professionalism and an easy to understand way. They kept me posted every step of the way. I would…

– Donna Fullmer

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

Hello my name is Kenny I was a tragic auto accident this accident will change me for life. I would like to share my experience with Ben glass law From the moment that I made a phone cal…

– Kenneth Fickes

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

My parents were involved in an accident where they were rear-ended on the highway. We wanted to ensure that they are properly compensated for their injuries and damages. We decided to g…

– Bolor Jargalsaikhan

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

Amazing! I was involved in a hit and run accident. Luckily I got a picture of their license plate and Ben Glass Law handled the rest for me! My team was Lisa and Tammy and they were fan…

– Tyree

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

It was a pleasure speaking to Krista Morgan at Ben Glass Law firm yesterday as she provided guidance and recommendations on how to proceed with my wife’s case. Thank you Krista.

– r.ariel olfato

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

Highly Recommended! โœจ BenGlassLaw exceeded all my expectations! Autumn and Melissa were absolutely amazingโ€”so patient with all my questions and incredibly helpful every step of the way…

– Min J. Kwon

Read More >

Case Results

View more >

$950,000

Personal Injury

Our 42 year old client was on a delivery to a factory in the western part of the state when a 500 pound garage door broke and fell on him, hitting him on the shoulder.

$390,000

Personal Injury

This BenGlassLaw client was a woman who had her leg severely fractured when a roll of carpet fell on her while she was shopping in a carpet store. She had to have two surgeries to repair the leg and it took her many months to recover.

$100,000

Auto Accidents

Client was rear-ended and suffered an orbital fracture. The first lawyer the client contacted wanted 41% of the recovery.

View more >

BenGlassLaw fights for the money you deserve after being injured in an accident.

At BenGlassLaw, our team of personal injury attorneys and specialists are passionate about fighting for you so that you can get back to living your life. We have the experience to understand your journey, along with aโ€ฏbest-in-class teamโ€ฏto support you throughout the entire settlement process. What makes our team unique?

  • Find the Money. We are great at finding insurance money. Our lawyers do a thorough examination of available insurance coverage by finding every dollar available to you. We leave no stone unturned to maximize your financial recovery.
  • Keep the Money. Weโ€™ll negotiate unpaid medical costs and liens so by the end of your personal injury case, you can hold onto as much of your money as possible.
  • Ongoing Support. The insurance industry wants this process to be complicated. They want it to be difficult for you to understand who should pay, when, and how much. After you hire us, we stop the insurance company from calling you so that your only job is to get medical care, tell us where you got it, and heal.โ€ฏOur team will take care ofโ€ฏeverythingโ€ฏelse.
AV Martindale Peer Rated Award Badge
Justia 10.0 Lawyer Rating Award Badge