Supreme Court Ruling Complicates ERISA Disability and Life Insurance Claims

By

Ben Glass

|

Owner and Long-Term Disability Attorney

Recently, the Supreme Court’s decision in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. ____ (2024), decided on June 28, 2024, has brought significant and potentially troubling implications for ERISA disability and life insurance claimants. While the regulations issued by the Department of Labor themselves remain unchanged post-Loper, the ruling may have fundamentally altered the legal landscape concerning how courts interpret these regulations.

Previously, courts adhered to Chevron deference, giving substantial weight to interpretations of ambiguous statutory language by administrative agencies such as the Department of Labor. However, the Loper decision overturned this practice. Now, courts are required to independently analyze and interpret the law, no longer automatically deferring to agency interpretations.

The Department of Labor is the administrative agency responsible for writing the ERISA claim regulations, which include both long-term disability and life insurance claims. The DOL has issued many โ€œinterpretationsโ€œ of its regulations.

To be clear, the regulations themselves remain valid. How they are applied in court will likely evolve. Courts are likely to play a more active role in interpreting regulatory language, potentially influencing outcomes in ERISA disability and life insurance cases moving forward.

The insurance industry will most certainly step up claim denials and will use this massive change in the law to more vigorously litigate cases. The decision overturns 40 years of precedent that has been cited in dozens of Supreme Court cases and thousands of lower court rulings.

Today, more than ever, claimants who are applying for, or who have had their employer-sponsored long-term disability or life insurance claims denied, need experienced ERISA attorney representation. The Supreme Court of the United States has made the appeal and litigation of these cases a lot more complicated and fraught with potential pitfalls.

It’s crucial for those navigating ERISA disability and life insurance claims to stay informed about these developments, as they may impact case strategies and outcomes. Keeping abreast of judicial interpretations and legal trends post-Loper will be essential for both practitioners and individuals involved in ERISA-related matters. Having a knowledgeable ERISA attorney can make a significant difference in understanding these issues and effectively advocating for your rights.

Why work with our long-term disability lawyers?

BenGlassLaw fights for disabled workers and their families across the nation. What makes us unique?

Experience Ben Glass has been representing disability claimants for over 25 years. Today, we handle more long-term disability claims than any other firm in the region. Lawyers throughout the Mid-Atlantic send their toughest cases to us.

Leadership Our work in long-term disability law is recognized and respected across the nation. Disability attorneys come to us to learn our techniques and processes.

Ongoing Support Once we get you back on claim, weโ€™ll handle the insurance company going forward, for as long as you receive LTD benefits. Let us worry about keeping you unclaimed and keeping the disability insurance company out of your hair.

Client Testimonials

View more >

5 Stars

Google Review

I was in a no fault accident and was injured. Melissa & Autumn handled my case with professionalism and an easy to understand way. They kept me posted every step of the way. I would…

– Donna Fullmer

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

Hello my name is Kenny I was a tragic auto accident this accident will change me for life. I would like to share my experience with Ben glass law From the moment that I made a phone cal…

– Kenneth Fickes

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

My parents were involved in an accident where they were rear-ended on the highway. We wanted to ensure that they are properly compensated for their injuries and damages. We decided to g…

– Bolor Jargalsaikhan

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

Amazing! I was involved in a hit and run accident. Luckily I got a picture of their license plate and Ben Glass Law handled the rest for me! My team was Lisa and Tammy and they were fan…

– Tyree

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

It was a pleasure speaking to Krista Morgan at Ben Glass Law firm yesterday as she provided guidance and recommendations on how to proceed with my wife’s case. Thank you Krista.

– r.ariel olfato

Read More >

5 Stars

Google Review

Highly Recommended! โœจ BenGlassLaw exceeded all my expectations! Autumn and Melissa were absolutely amazingโ€”so patient with all my questions and incredibly helpful every step of the way…

– Min J. Kwon

Read More >

Case Results

View more >

$3 Million

Long-Term Disability Insurance Claims

High earning salesperson with โ€œstiff person syndromeโ€ awarded $10,000 a month in disability benefits

$1.825 Million

Long-Term Disability

Global HR Business Partner suffering from Rheumatoid Arthritis has long-term disability benefits restored after Hartford Insurance denies disability claim

$1.4 Million

Long-Term Disability

After being injured in a car accident, a software engineer is awarded disability benefits on appeal after getting denied by the insurance company.

$1.3 Million

Long-Term Disability Insurance Claims

Fairfax County Special Education Teacher Now Eligible to Collect Nearly $1.3 Million in Disability Benefits Following Successful Long Term Disability Appeal

$1.2 Million

Long-Term Disability Insurance Claims

Sometimes the coolest companies to work for donโ€™t always have the coolest benefit plans.

$1 Million

Long-Term Disability

We fought for our client against an insurance company that ignored facts and terminated benefits on a very minuscule review.

$986,000

Long-Term Disability

A public school teacher was diagnosed with chronic lyme disease. Short term disability claim was denied when insurance company said she was misdiagnosed.

$947,394

Long-Term Disability Insurance Claims

CIGNA reinstates long-term disability benefits after Pro Se appeal denied. Second appeal is successful. Almost $1,000,000 in lifetime benefits

$761,380

Long-Term Disability

Long-Term Disability Client with Ankylosing Spondylitis Wins Against Prudential Disability Insurance

$750,000

Long-Term Disability

BenGlassLaw Long-Term Disability Team Wins Benefits for Physical Therapist Assistant ceased working due to a multitude of debilitating symptoms

View more >

BenGlassLaw fights for wrongfully denied workers across the nation. 

Since 1995, BenGlassLaw has been helping sick, injured, and disabled workers fight unfair claim denials, get the benefits they paid for, and get their lives back on track. We are passionate about restoring our clientโ€™s denied benefits because insurance policies should be part of the solution, not a cause of additional stress. What makes our team unique?

  • Our Experience. We file more long-term disability appeals and lawsuits than any other firm in the Mid-Atlantic. (Source: Pacer, the official government site for Federal Court lawsuits) 
  • Our Leadership.  Our work in ERISA Law is recognized and respected across the nation. We speak at national events and teach other national disability attorneys about our own techniques and processes for handling ERISA and life insurance denials.
  • Ongoing Support. Once we get our clients back on claim, itโ€™s never them vs the insurance company again. For as long as our client receive benefits, we handle the insurance company โ€” which is why we manage over $33 million in future disability benefits on behalf of our clients.
AV Martindale Peer Rated Award Badge
Justia 10.0 Lawyer Rating Award Badge